Traffic-based methodology to develop peak Heat Release Rate probability distributions for sizing road tunnels ventilation systems when using a probabilistic approach

Sonia  Fernandez; Charles  Fleischmann; Daniel  Nilsson; Alberto  Fraile

doi:10.59400/mea2145

Traffic-based methodology to develop peak Heat Release Rate probability distributions for sizing road tunnels ventilation systems when using a probabilistic approach

Sonia Fernandez Sociedad Ibérica de Construcciones Eléctricas S.A. (SICE), 28108 Madrid, Spain
Charles Fleischmann Department of Civil & Natural Resources Engineering, University of Canterbury, Christchurch 8041, New Zealand
Daniel Nilsson Department of Civil & Natural Resources Engineering, University of Canterbury, Christchurch 8041, New Zealand
Alberto Fraile Universidad Politécnica de Madrid, 28040 Madrid, Spain

Article ID: 2145

Keywords: road tunnels; tunnel ventilation; stochastic analysis; probability distributions; design fire; traffic statistics

Abstract

Road tunnels are a crucial part of today’s transport infrastructures worldwide. Among the installed systems, the tunnel ventilation is key, as in the case of fire, it establishes and keeps appropriate conditions for self-evacuation and emergency services operations. Recent works propose using a probabilistic approach to assess road tunnels ventilation systems’ capacity for fire scenarios. Under this approach, key design variables are defined based on probability distributions. From these distributions, the analysis uses the different possible values of the variables, including lower and upper limits as well as mean and characteristic values. The results obtained with this proposed probabilistic approach allow not only designers, but also tunnel operators and administrations, to quantify the reliability of the capacity of the ventilation system, assess its probability of failure, and define safety levels. This paper illustrates a methodology to define the design fire as a probability distribution for sizing road tunnels ventilation systems when applying the above-mentioned probabilistic approach. The methodology uses traffic information (crucial in road tunnels) and correlates it to peak Heat Release Rate (HRR) values from published reports by PIARC to obtain the design fire variable in terms of peak HRR probability distributions. The methodology is applied to two case study tunnels with different characteristics. The obtained results for the two tunnels are then compared and analyzed to peak HRR values normally recommended and used when sizing road tunnels ventilation systems to understand the uncertainty and sensitivity of the results.

References

[1]Steunpunt T. Recommendations for ventilation of traffic tunnels (Dutch). Thieme GrafiMedia Groep; 2005.

[2]Fernández S, Fraile A, Del Rey I, et al. Probabilistic approach for longitudinal ventilation system design in fire situations. In: Proceedings of the 15th International Symposium on Aerodynamics, Ventilation & Fire in Tunnels; 18–20 September 2013; Barcelona, Spain.

[3]Pachera M, Weyenberge BV, Deckers X. Development of a full probabilistic risk model to assess the performance of longitudinal ventilation system for fires in tunnel. In: Proceedings of the Tunnel Safety and Ventilation—9th International Conference; 12–14 June 2018; Graz, Austria.

[4]Fernandez Martin S, del Rey Llorente I, de Lerma AF. Tunnel Ventilation Analysis Using a Probabilistic Approach: Case Study, Fire in Road Tunnels with Longitudinal Ventilation. Fire Technology. 2020; 57.

[5]Fernandez Martin S. Application of Probabilistic Methods for the Optimization of Ventilation Systems in Road Tunnels [PhD thesis]. Polytechnic University of Madrid; 2023.

[6]Ingason H, Li YZ, Lonnermark A. Tunnel Fire Dynamics. Springer; 2015. pp. 1–134.

[7]National Fire Protection Association. NFPA 502, Standard for Road Tunnels, Bridges, and Other Limited Access Highways. National Fire Protection Association; 2017.

[8]PIARC. Design Fire Characteristics for Road Tunnels. PIARC; 2017.

[9]Carvel R, Beard A. The Handbook of Tunnel Fire Safety. Thomas Telford; 2005.

[10]CETU. The Pilot Files, Ventilation (France). Ministère de l’Équipement, des Transports, du Logement, du Tourisme et de la Mer direction des routes; 2003.

[11]RABT. Guidelines for the equipment and operation of road tunnels (German). Research Society for Road and Traffic Engineering; 2006.

[12]NCHRP. Design Fires in Road Tunnels. NCHRP; 2011.

[13]Carvel R. Fire size in tunnels [PhD thesis]. Heriot-Watt University; 2004.

[14]Bouwdienst Rijkswaterstaat. Project ‘Safety Test’: Fire Test Report (Dutch). Bouwdienst Rijkswaterstaat; 2002.

[15]Ingason H. State of the Art of Tunnel Fire Research. Fire Safety Science. 2008; 9.

[16]TRB. Highway Capacity Manual. Transportation Research Board; 2000.

[17]PIARC. Experience with significant incidents in road tunnels. PIARC; 2017.

[18]Hadjisophocleous GV, Mehaffey JR. Fire Scenarios. In: SFPE Handbook of Fire Protection Engineering. Springer; 2016.

[19]Meacham, B. Toward next generation performance-based building regulatory systems. In: Proceedings of SFPE 11th Conference on performance-based codes and fire safety design methods; 23-25 May 2016; Warsaw, Poland.

Published

2025-04-02

How to Cite

Fernandez, S., Fleischmann, C., Nilsson, D., & Fraile, A. (2025). Traffic-based methodology to develop peak Heat Release Rate probability distributions for sizing road tunnels ventilation systems when using a probabilistic approach. Mechanical Engineering Advances, 3(2), 2145. https://doi.org/10.59400/mea2145

Download Citation

Issue

Vol. 3 No. 2 (2025)

Section

Article

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

In the paper, the MATLAB-Simulink model of simulation of operation of the fast light innovative regional train from “Serbian Railways” in traction and braking mode is exposed where changes are observed: stator currents of three-phase traction motors, traction electric motor speeds and electric multiple units, electromagnetic torque on the rotor shaft of the traction electric motor, and direct current bus voltage. The model allowed review of the listed parameters for: different allowed values of contact network voltage and total voltage distortion at the place of connection of the electric multiple unit to the contact network; different mechanical loads of the electric multiple unit and traction electric motor; and different train speeds and rotations of traction electric motors. Appropriate conclusions were made through the analysis of the simulation results obtained.

This paper defines vehicles and buildings as main sources of United Kingdom (UK) carbon dioxide (CO₂) and seeks to cut such emissions using green hydrogen made from combined wind and solar energy. Combustion vehicles powered by fossil petroleum emit near half of UK climate-warming CO₂ while buildings heated by natural gas provide a third. First, current UK grid problems are defined: Electricity, gas and petroleum grids. Refueling green vehicles has been a particular problem. Then experiments on the private wire community of Keele University show how green hydrogen could integrate both green vehicles and buildings. Next, the model supply chain is planned and tested. Finally, experiments and calculations are outlined, analyzing the optimum system design criteria proposed. We conclude that economic green hydrogen can displace petroleum in vehicles, while powering buildings instead of natural gas. Also, the prospect in 2024 is that profits can be made all along the green hydrogen supply chain, such that new businesses involved in local private clean communities can cost less than the National Grid monopoly and other dominant fossil energy companies.

Presently, dynamic impacts occurrences caused by car crashes have been frequently reported. Statistical results from different articles indicate that vehicle crashworthiness of bridge pier supersedes the other events. However, majority of the published articles focusses on sustainability and finding severity of distressed pier due to impact correlating faster construction methods, like accelerated bridge construction (ABC). This article is an attempt to examine post impacted behavior of a commonly used connector in ABC for resisting short duration shock. Static and dynamic performance analyses of a connector embedded within a coupler system has been examined. A representative ABC pier with the standardized and selected material properties collected from manufacturer’s data has been utilized. Coupler composite materials consisting of a hollow uniform cross-section cast iron cylinder filled up with specified concrete grout conforms higher strength. The performance examination has been conducted by numerical modeling using finite element method (FEM). A commercially used software ANSYS has been utilized for carrying out the simulations. To investigate the post impact dynamic behavior, mesh-independent studies seems inevitable and hence are executed to evaluate dynamic impact factor (DIF). Sensitivity studies are carried out for validating results in precision. The DIF of the main reinforcing tensile steel embedded into the grout placed inside the connector has been determined. Results captured from simulations to identify material properties at plastic stage in sustaining such load have been conducted. The results provide significant information that aids opting for selecting suitable connectors for attaining help the design offices.